Why Reading a Script Can Ruin Your Videos
There's a good reason why professional television presenters make reading from an autocue look so easy.
They've spent years learning how to do it.
And yet, when people decide to make videos for social media, one of the first things they often do is write themselves a script.
I understand why.
You want to get everything right. You don't want to forget anything. And you certainly don't want to find yourself staring into the camera wondering what on earth you were talking about.
So you write down exactly what you want to say.
Problem solved.
Except you've potentially just created a much bigger problem.
Because reading a script and sounding like you're having a natural conversation are two completely different things.
And that's something I've learned from years of presenting and helping other people feel comfortable in front of a camera.

1. Reading a script naturally is a skill
Watch a really good television presenter reading from an autocue.
You probably won't even realise they're doing it.
They'll make eye contact with the camera, use natural expressions, vary their pace and deliver everything as though they're talking directly to you.
It looks effortless.
It isn't.
Reading from an autocue convincingly takes practice.
Lots of it.
And there's another skill involved before the presenter even opens their mouth.
Writing the script.
Because the way we write and the way we speak are often completely different.
Think about how you'd explain something to a friend.
You'd probably use shorter sentences, contractions, pauses and the occasional expression that wouldn't look particularly elegant on a page.
But that's how people actually talk.
A script written for somebody to read aloud needs to reflect that.
And ideally, it needs to reflect the personality of the person delivering it.
Otherwise, even a perfectly written script can sound terribly unnatural.
The best presenters understand this. Some are so comfortable with an autocue that they can glance at the words and improvise around them.
But that level of confidence doesn't arrive the moment somebody puts a screen in front of your camera.
2. Your personality can disappear
Here's a little experiment.
Find something you've written recently.
An email, perhaps.
Now read it aloud.
Not silently in your head. Actually say the words.
Notice anything?
There's a good chance your voice changes slightly.
Your rhythm becomes different.
You might emphasise words you wouldn't normally emphasise.
You may even sound a little more formal than usual.
That's because reading and speaking naturally involve different habits.
And when you're concentrating on getting every word right, it's surprisingly easy to forget about everything else.
Your expressions.
Your gestures.
Your enthusiasm.
All those little things that make you recognisably you.
For an independent musician, that's particularly important.
People already have opportunities to hear your music.
But when you talk to camera, you're giving them an opportunity to get to know the person behind it.
Perhaps you're explaining what inspired a song.
Or telling a story from the recording studio.
Or sharing something that happened at a gig.
Those moments are valuable because they're personal.
And the last thing you want is to sound as though you're reading a statement prepared by your solicitor.
3. People can tell when something isn't right
I often say something when I'm coaching people on camera.
You don't have to be an actor to spot a bad actor.
Think about that for a moment.
Most of us have never studied acting.
We don't understand all the techniques involved.
But when we watch somebody delivering a dreadful performance, we know.
Something feels wrong.
And exactly the same thing can happen when somebody reads a script badly.
Perhaps their eyes keep moving from side to side.
Perhaps the emphasis falls on the wrong words.
Perhaps the delivery is just a little too polished, or a little too flat.
You might not consciously notice any of those things.
But you can sense that the person isn't speaking naturally.
And when you're trying to build a connection with an audience, that matters.
Because people don't just respond to what you say.
They respond to how you say it.
So should you never use a script?
Of course not.
There are plenty of situations where a script is absolutely the right tool.
Perhaps you're making a documentary.
Maybe you're recording a carefully structured piece to camera.
Or you need to communicate something where the wording has to be precise.
I use scripts myself.
But I also understand the work involved in making them sound natural.
And that's the distinction.
A script isn't a shortcut to becoming a good presenter.
If you're comfortable reading from one, brilliant.
If you've practised and developed the skill, use it.
But if you're an independent musician making informal videos for social media, you might find there's a much easier way.
Try talking points instead
Rather than writing out every word, try making a few notes.
I generally recommend thinking about three things before you press record.
How are you going to start?
Your opening matters.
You want to give people a reason to stop scrolling and listen.
It might be a surprising statement, an interesting question or the beginning of a story.
What are the main points you want to cover?
Write down two or three things you definitely want to mention.
Not complete sentences.
Just enough to remind yourself where you're going.
How are you going to finish?
Know where the story ends.
Otherwise, you can find yourself going round in circles, trying to remember whether you've already made your point.
Once you've got those three things, put the notes somewhere you can glance at them if you need to.
Then talk.
Imagine you're explaining something to a friend.
Because, essentially, that's what you're doing.
You don't have to get everything right in one take
Here's another thing worth remembering.
You're making a video. You're not broadcasting live to the nation.
If you stumble over a word, stop.
If you forget what you're saying, have a look at your notes.
If you suddenly think of a better way to explain something, try it again.
You can edit the mistakes out afterwards.
And sometimes I'd encourage you to leave a few of them in.
A little hesitation, an unexpected laugh or the occasional "erm" isn't necessarily a disaster.
It's how people speak.
Of course, you don't want every sentence interrupted by a lengthy search for the next word.
But there's a difference between sounding natural and sounding completely unprepared.
With a little practice, you'll find that balance.
And the more you do it, the easier it becomes.
The camera isn't the problem
One of the things I've noticed when working with people who are uncomfortable on camera is that they're often perfectly capable of talking about their subject.
Ask a musician about their favourite guitar, the inspiration behind a song or something that happened during recording, and you might struggle to get them to stop talking.
Put a camera in front of them and suddenly they forget how to construct a sentence.
The knowledge hasn't disappeared.
Neither has their personality.
They've simply become too conscious of the camera.
And trying to remember a carefully written script can make that feeling even worse.
So take some of the pressure away.
Know what you want to say.
Give yourself a little structure.
And then allow yourself to speak naturally.
Because the people watching aren't expecting a flawless television performance.
They're interested in you.
And if you can make them feel as though you're talking to them rather than reading at them, you're already doing something right.
The best thing you can bring to a video isn't a perfect script. It's your personality.



